Voodoo Man Redux – Hypnosis, Going Native, Big Brains, and Social Control, Part 1

UPDATE 1 – ADDED MEDIA

Introduction

In this multi-part essay (replete with multimedia content), we begin with sheer enjoyment of schlock horror (as well as more serious films), and move on to discuss social, political and spiritual issues as reflected in the cultural mirror provided by film, TV, and literature. (Media files will be added gradually. Please check back for updates.)

We watch scenes from the 1944 horror film Voodoo Man, comparing it to Manos, The Hands of Fate, “The Brain of Morbius,” and “Dr. Tongue’s 3D House of Stewardesses.” Also discussed: But I’m a Cheerleader, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, “The Happiness Patrol,” and The Front. We ponder forms of social control driven by nativist stereotypes, including the ‘hypnotized by swamis’ trope. How do such tropes feed into the anti-cult narrative used to justify targeting minority adherents with coercive attempts at behaviour modification?

We’re in for some fun, but also serious film criticism and wide-ranging social commentary. Perhaps what’s needed is a ‘giant brain’ to process all this information! But are giant brains really all they’re cracked up to be? We examine clips from Desk Set, Britannia Hospital, “The Sixth Finger” (an Outer Limits episode), and “The War Machines” (a Doctor Who story). Also discussed: the sci-fi novels Last and First Men (Olaf Stapledon) and That Hideous Strength (C. S. Lewis). The latter, published in 1945, contains an early example of deprogramming.

Since actress Louise Fletcher had roles in both Cuckoo’s Nest and Deep Space Nine, this facilitates an easy ‘modulation’ into related subject areas. We’ll discuss the therapeutic disguise of social control, and changing attitudes toward meditation, yoga, and new religious movements, real or fictional.

We’ll travel through the McCarthy Era and the Cold War, examining how Britain’s response to the communist threat differed from America’s. Sources include the films I’m All Right Jack and The Spy Who Came In From The Cold. We’ll glimpse America’s pre-McCarthy flirtations with socialism (before it became taboo) via the 1935 film version of Eugene O’Neill’s play Ah, Wilderness!, set in 1906.

Returning to the ‘going native’ trope introduced by Voodoo Man, we’ll discuss the case of Sara Chapman Bull, an American disciple of Swami Vivekananda in the early 1900s who found that her devotion to the Vedanta Society was problematized and medicalized in order to bar her from implementing her last will and testament.

Some of the unifying principles we will uncover are ultra-rationalism, ultra-secularism, and ultra-conformism — including burgeoning beliefs encountered in the 20th century that man must become all brain, or create a giant electronic brain which will be superior by virtue of having no feeling, sensation, or human sensibility; that society must be reshaped to conform to a secular scientific model of the universe; and that individual variations in behavior based on minority spiritual, economic, political or cultural views must be stamped out, both for the good of the individual, and the general welfare of society. By contrast, the author will argue for religious liberty, and the freedom of the individual to construct an identity which he or she finds livable.

Fasten your seatbelts!

Deprogramming Revisited Part 1

Revisiting a deprogramming complaint and asking how much has really changed. Are religious differences not better solved through acceptance, tolerance, and love? Plus extended historical analysis.

UPDATE 3. Jennifer Jacobs was a member of an American Buddhist group in the 1980s. According to a sworn declaration which she filed in California in 1991, she was subjected to a kidnapping type deprogramming. She names Joe Szimhart as one of the deprogrammers who held her captive and subjected her to psychological abuse. The complaint speaks for itself, and you can read it in full on the CESNUR site here. I want to present some highlights from her declaration which I find relevant to the current deprogramming/exit counseling scene in 2020:

International Women’s Day: Temple-Song-Hearts music group and more

BETA VERSION What can one say after such beautiful music? Except that it helps explain why I write in favour of freedom of religion and religious tolerance, because only when these things flourish can we enjoy the fruits. Here, the fruits are beautiful music and a presentation filled with light by women who come from different countries across a borderless Europe. But did you notice what language they are singing in? The language is Bengali, which was Sri Chinmoy’s mother tongue.

When the world is at peace and there is freedom of movement, people are free to gather what they find beautiful and meaningful from the world’s cultures, to create something uniquely their own. What wonderful music with which to celebrate International Women’s Day!

The ACLU and Religious Freedom, Part 4

What is the ideal balance between faith and reason? Do people have a right to choose faith over reason, at least in matters of faith? The U.S. Constitution says yes.

We’ve been exploring the problem of vilification of spiritual minorities by anti-cult groups. In Part 3 we discussed how hate material poisons the public information space, making people afraid to follow their conscience in spiritual matters for fear of what may be done to them by aggressive majoritarians.

Our consistent theme has been that even as anti-cult tactics have shifted from physical coercion to psychological coercion, the ACLU should still be concerned about the manner in which some anti-cult activities abridge the civil rights of minority adherents.

The ACLU and Religious Freedom, Part 1

The ACLU has often fought for the rights of minority adherents, including Eastern spiritual seekers. BRAVO ACLU!

I might not be able to avoid criticising some attorneys for harassing minority faith groups. But my purpose here today is to praise the American Civil Liberties Union for often coming to the rescue of minority adherents.

The backdrop for understanding these issues is this: America was built on noble ideals of religious freedom which are part of its very soul. Yet, religious freedom is not a given; it must often be won and re-won by successive generations of immigrant groups or new faith groups which spring up indigenously. Counterbalancing the ideals of religious freedom, we sometimes find that conformism, populism, and authoritarianism lead America in a quite different, less flattering direction.